Bold Bean Co
Your Cart
LET US KNOW WHAT YOU THINK
Dietary key
-
V
Vegetarian
-
V*
Vegetarian Option
-
Ve
Vegan
-
Ve*
Vegan Option
-
G
Gluten-Free
-
G*
Gluten-Free Option
-
D
Dairy-Free
-
D*
Dairy-Free Option
Carbonara Butter Beans
Aka, Car-bean-ara.
This recipe is by MasterChef Quarter Finalist 2025, Finley Richards. You can even watch him make the recipe here!
"Through pure technique and principle this recipe works. It has the same viscosity and mouthfeel as a carbonara, whilst also delivering flavour profile wise. Plus you get the health benefits of a nutritionally denser meal than your typical carbonara, with lots of fibre and protein from the beans. What’s not to love?" - Finely.
You can check out more of Finley's delicious recipes on his Substack here.
Ingredients
1 whole egg
3 egg yolks
200g pecorino or parmesan
Large handful of peppercorns
250g Guanciale (or the best quality bacon lardons you can find!)
Shop The Recipe
Directions
Crack 4 eggs into a bowl, using one whole egg and 3 yolks. Whisk until smooth. Then, grate in the majority of your pecorino, about 50 grams at a time. Whisking with a fork as you go and ensuring the mixture is as smooth as can be. Set aside.
Take a large handful of peppercorns and put them into a frying pan. Toast gently over a medium heat until you can start to smell the peppery aroma. Pour into a pestle and mortar and grind it down. Not to a smooth powder - you still want some bite from the slightly cracked peppercorns, so aim for a coarse texture here.
Slice the guanciale into strips about an inch long and a one cm wide - you don’t need to be overly specific here, just keep in mind they will reduce in size once rendered down.
Take a cold pan and put the sliced guanciale in, without any oil. Turn the heat onto a low/medium flame and slowly render the fat from the guanciale. So low and slow is the trick.
Once golden in colour and the fat has been sucked out from the heat, take your guanciale out, but keep all the oil/residue left in the pan. Set the guanciale aside and pour the remnants of oil into the cheesy egg mixture. Whisking quickly and constantly so it doesn’t scramble the eggs. To stop it from scrambling, wait for the oil to cool down a touch before pouring it in and add it little by little.
Strain the beans into a sieve over a bowl to catch the liquid. Fill the empty jar about ¼ with water, shake and pour that into the bowl. Mix well to combine. This will act in a similar way to pasta water for. the right texture and viscosity of the sauce.
Add the butter beans to a heavy-bottomed frying pan. Add 3/4 tbsp’s of the bean liquid and gently simmer. Don’t stir too much with a utensil, instead just move the pan in a circular motion so the beans move without needing to break them up at all with a spoon for example. You want to keep them intact. Simmer for 3-4 minutes.
Gradually spoon in the eggy cheesy mixture and stir, stir, stir. Keep the heat low and keep it moving. You can also add bits of the bean liquid to loosen it up. Then add more of the egg and cheese mix, and more of the liquid.
Add a handful of guanciale and a pinch of the ground down peppercorns and keep stirring. You should have the consistency of a carbonara at this point. A beautifully emulsified, eggy, cheesy peppery mixture. Rich and creamy with a sauce that isn’t scrambled but silky and glossy. The bean liquid can be used to help rescue the dish if the sauce is too thick or scrambling. Just add more liquid and keep stirring to emulsify and reduce.
Serve into bowls or plates, top with the guanciale, black pepper and loads more grated pecorino.
More Recipes